Have you ever wondered why, in light of the slew of “I survived Orthodoxy but saw the secular light!” essays and books, there no counter-flood of similar writing by some of the many who came from other Jewish places to Orthodoxy?
Why are there are no vivid descriptions of what impelled some Orthodox Jew toward traditional Jewish observance? Why no accounts of the emptiness of secular lives they experienced, or the inadequacy they perceived in less observant ones?
Are there no tales to tell of parents who deprived their children of even a rudimentary Jewish education? Who responded negatively to their progeny’s explorations of their Jewish roots? Or who lived lives that contradicted what they preached to their young?
My thoughts on the matter can be read here.